← Registry

InsufficientBias in credit decisions2021

Allegation that the Apple Card credit algorithm gave women lower limits, reviewed by New York regulator

Consequence: No finding of harm from sex-based underwriting. The regulator did find weak customer service and transparency, which Goldman Sachs and Apple took steps to fix.

Claim

In November 2019, a customer reported that he received a credit limit 20 times his wife's on the Apple Card despite joint finances, and attributed it to sex discrimination by an opaque algorithm run by Goldman Sachs Bank.

Evidence

The New York State Department of Financial Services reviewed several thousand pages of records, interviewed complainants and ran a regression analysis on underwriting data for nearly 400,000 New York applicants. It found women and men with equivalent credit characteristics had similar outcomes, and the bank could explain each complainant's decision by factors such as credit score, debt and income.

Causal strength

Not established: the regulator found no evidence of disparate treatment or disparate impact. The report also says its result does not prove the product is free of the wider problems of credit scoring. The allegation is graded on whether the evidence supports it, not on how widely it was repeated.

Bears on

A case bears on an obligation when it informs how that obligation applies to AI. This is not legal advice and not a finding that anyone violated it.

Grade history

  • November 21, 2026InsufficientInitial grade at publication

Sources

Not affiliated with TruRate (trurate.com).