TruthRate evidence pack

Widely used health risk algorithm scored Black patients as healthier than equally sick White patients

Grade as of November 22, 2026

Verified

Bias in risk scoring · 2019

Consequence

In the studied health system, Black patients with the same risk score had more chronic illness than White patients. Correcting the gap would raise the Black share of patients auto-identified for extra care from 17.7% to 46.5%.

Claim

An algorithm used to select patients for care-management programs used past health costs as a stand-in for health needs. Because Black patients generated lower costs at the same level of illness, they received lower risk scores and were less often selected.

Evidence

A peer-reviewed study in Science (Obermeyer, Powers, Vogeli and Mullainathan, October 25, 2019) using records from a large academic hospital: 6,079 Black and 43,539 White patients, with the algorithm's inputs, outputs and objective all observable. At the 97th percentile of risk, Black patients had 26.3% more chronic conditions than White patients.

Causal strength

Direct and documented mechanism: the authors show the cost label causes the gap, and a revised label that blends health and cost predictions reduced the bias by 84% in their tests. The data come from one health system, so the exact figures describe that system.

Bears on

  • Model risk management (SR 11-7 and OCC 2011-12)
  • Fair lending (ECOA and the Fair Housing Act)

A case bears on an obligation when it informs how that obligation applies to AI. This is not legal advice and not a finding that anyone violated it.

Grade history

  • November 21, 2026: Verified. Initial grade at publication

Sources

  1. Dissecting racial bias in an algorithm used to manage the health of populations, Science 366(6464) (Primary; Peer-reviewed study)
    https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/science.aax2342
  2. PubMed record (Secondary; Index entry)
    https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/31649194

Cite this

TruthRate. “Widely used health risk algorithm scored Black patients as healthier than equally sick White patients.” Graded Verified as of November 22, 2026. https://truthrate.com/case/health-risk-algorithm-underestimated-black-patients-needs/pack?asof=2026-11-22. Retrieved November 22, 2026.

The grade is as of the date shown. The claim, evidence and sources are shown as currently published. Grading method: https://truthrate.com/methodology